The Supreme Court raised the standard damages courts award to crime victims. In People v. Flores, decided November 4, 2026, it updated the Jugueta and Tulagan benchmarks for civil indemnity, moral, exemplary and temperate damages, citing inflation, cost of living and wage growth, and ordered that all criminal cases follow the new tables in its decision.
Legal question
How much may a court award a crime victim, or the victim's heirs, as civil indemnity, moral damages, exemplary damages and temperate damages, and what changed when the Supreme Court decided People v. Flores?
Applicable laws and rules
- Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 111, Section 1(a) — the civil action for civil liability arising from the offense is deemed instituted with the criminal action, unless the offended party waives it, reserves it, or filed it first
- Civil Code, Article 2206 — damages for death caused by a crime "shall be at least three thousand pesos," with no ceiling
- Civil Code, Article 2219 — moral damages in criminal offenses resulting in physical injuries and in seduction, abduction, rape or other lascivious acts, among others
- Civil Code, Article 2224 — temperate damages when some pecuniary loss was suffered but its amount cannot be proved with certainty
- Civil Code, Articles 2229 and 2230 — exemplary damages, which in criminal offenses may be imposed when the crime was committed with one or more aggravating circumstances
- People v. Jugueta, G.R. No. 202124 (Supreme Court En Banc, April 5, 2016) — the earlier schedule of damages by crime and penalty
- People v. Tulagan (Supreme Court En Banc, 2019) — damages in sexual abuse cases
- People v. Flores, G.R. No. 278376 (Supreme Court En Banc, November 4, 2026) — the recalibrated guidelines
Why this matters
For most victims of violent and sexual crimes, the money a court awards comes through the criminal case itself, not a separate lawsuit. The amounts courts use are largely fixed by Supreme Court benchmarks, and the main ones had not changed since 2016 and 2019. People v. Flores resets them for every criminal case decided from now on, which matters to victims, families of people killed, prosecutors and accused persons alike. For related protections, see our guide on protection orders under the VAWC law and our article on psychological violence under RA 9262.
What happened
- April 5, 2016: in People v. Jugueta, the Court En Banc set standard amounts of civil indemnity, moral and exemplary damages by crime, penalty and stage of the offense.
- 2019: in People v. Tulagan, the Court set amounts for sexual abuse cases.
- November 4, 2026: in People v. Flores, an appeal involving a child who was six years old when the offenses were committed, the Court En Banc revisited both frameworks and adopted new tables.
- November 16, 2026: the Court's Office of the Spokesperson released a summary. The full decision, with the tables, will be posted on the Court's website.
What civil indemnity, moral, exemplary and temperate damages are
- Civil indemnity ex delicto is awarded on proof of the crime itself, without proof of a specific loss. For death caused by a crime, Article 2206 of the Civil Code sets a minimum of ₱3,000 but no ceiling, which is why the Court can raise the benchmark.
- Moral damages compensate mental anguish, fright and suffering. Article 2219 allows them for criminal offenses resulting in physical injuries and for rape and other lascivious acts.
- Exemplary damages are imposed "by way of example or correction for the public good" (Article 2229). In criminal cases, Article 2230 allows them when the crime was committed with aggravating circumstances, and they go to the offended party, separate from any fine.
- Temperate damages cover a loss that was clearly suffered but cannot be proved with certainty (Article 2224), such as funeral expenses without receipts.
In a death case, these awards go to the victim's heirs. The convicted person pays them as part of the judgment.
The old Jugueta amounts
People v. Jugueta set these benchmarks, among others, each for civil indemnity, moral damages and exemplary damages:
- Crimes such as murder and qualified rape where the penalty would have been death but is reduced to reclusion perpetua by RA 9346: ₱100,000 each.
- Crimes punished by reclusion perpetua otherwise, including simple rape: ₱75,000 each.
- Homicide and other deaths under divisible penalties, consummated: ₱50,000 civil indemnity and ₱50,000 moral damages, plus ₱50,000 exemplary damages if an aggravating circumstance was proved.
- Temperate damages of ₱50,000 when no documentary evidence of burial or funeral expenses is presented.
Lower amounts applied to frustrated and attempted crimes.
The new amounts
People v. Flores replaces these figures with new tables, which are in the decision itself and are not reproduced in the Court's summary. The summary gives the amounts applied in the case:
- Qualified rape of a minor: civil indemnity ex delicto, moral damages and exemplary damages each rose from ₱100,000 to ₱325,000.
- Acts of lasciviousness: each award rose from ₱50,000 to ₱175,000.
The Court also set specific amounts of temperate damages for losses from death or injury that cannot be proved with receipts, and adjusted the awards for crimes involving death, which it said warrant the highest ranges because the loss is permanent. It explained that the benchmark for intentional death is a calibrated increase over the current benchmark for death caused by negligence, reflecting the greater culpability of intentional crime, "without suggesting that the value of a human life differs depending on the manner of death." Check the full decision, once posted, for the amount that applies to a particular crime.
Why the Court raised the amounts
According to the Court's summary, later legislation, changes in jurisprudence and present economic conditions made the Jugueta and Tulagan figures outdated. Inflation, cost of living, wage growth and fiscal stability are relevant, but the Court said the review "should not be reduced to a mere mechanical computation of inflation," because harm to bodily integrity, dignity and personal autonomy cannot be measured in money alone. Its new parameters for sexual offenses and other heinous crimes look at the penalty prescribed by law, the nature and stage of the offense, the extent of injury or loss, and the lived experience of the victim and survivors, with particular weight on sexual violence against children and abuse of trust or authority. The Court added that the amounts are not immutable: courts may award more when the circumstances warrant.
Which cases the new amounts apply to
In the dispositive portion, the Court directed that "henceforth, all awards of civil indemnity ex delicto, moral damages, exemplary damages, and temperate damages in all criminal cases shall conform to the amounts enumerated in the tables" in the decision. The summary does not say more about cases already final, and a final judgment is generally no longer open to change. For cases still being decided, whether at trial or on appeal, courts are directed to apply the new tables.
How victims claim the damages and how interest runs
Under Rule 111, Section 1 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, the civil action for damages arising from the crime is deemed filed together with the criminal case, so a victim does not need a separate lawsuit unless they waive it, reserve the right to file it separately, or filed it first. The prosecutor presents the evidence, and the judgment of conviction includes the awards.
In Flores, the awards earn legal interest of 6% a year from the finality of the decision until fully paid. The Court also directed trial courts to have the Department of Social Welfare and Development refer the child victim, with her guardian's consent, to the appropriate Rape Crisis Center.
What individuals should know
If you are a victim or the family of a victim, the damages are claimed through the criminal case, and you should tell the prosecutor about expenses and losses, with receipts where you have them. Temperate damages cover some losses you cannot document, but proven actual expenses can be claimed in full.
If you are an accused person, a conviction now carries higher civil awards than under the 2016 and 2019 benchmarks, on top of the penalty. The awards are separate from any fine and run with 6% interest once the judgment is final.
Collecting is a separate problem: an award is only as good as the convicted person's ability to pay. Ask the prosecutor or your lawyer about executing the civil liability after judgment.
Ask PHLaw.AI
Try: "My brother was killed and the accused was convicted of murder. What damages can our family receive after People v. Flores, and do we need to file a separate case?"
Sources
- SC Recalibrates Civil Damages in Criminal Cases, Updates Guidelines for Awards to Victims and Survivors — Supreme Court of the Philippines (November 16, 2026)
- People v. Jugueta, G.R. No. 202124, April 5, 2016 — LawPhil
- Civil Code of the Philippines (Articles 2206, 2219, 2224, 2229, 2230) — LawPhil
- Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 111 — LawPhil